Even a potentially devastating event such as divorce can have some positive health outcomes for post-menopausal women, UA researchers found.
[Photo: Dr. Cynthia Thomson]
Women who marry after menopause may gain more weight than women who remain single, a new study in the Journal of Women’s Health suggests.
For women who marry later in life, a few extra pounds may accompany their nuptials, a new study led by the University of Arizona College of Medicine and the Mel and Enid Zuckerman College of Public Health suggests.
On the other hand, older women who go through a divorce or separation may lose weight and see some positive changes in their health, according to the research, which is forthcoming in the Journal of Women’s Health.
The researchers’ findings are based on data from the Women’s Health Initiative’s (WHI) observational study. The Women’s Health Initiative was a prevention study initiated by the National Institutes of Health in 1991 to address health issues in postmenopausal women. More than 160,000 women ages 50 to 79 participated in the initiative’s three clinical trials and observational study over the course of 15 years. Co-author Dr. Cynthia Thomson, a professor of public health in the University of Arizona Mel and Enid Zuckerman College of Public Health, was the initiative’s principal investigator at the study’s UA site.
“Earlier studies on marriage and divorce have shown that marriage is usually associated with a longer lifespan and fewer health problems, while divorce is associated with higher mortality,” said the study’s lead author, Dr. Randa Kutob, an associate professor of family and community medicine and director of the UA College of Medicine’s Office of Continuing Medical Education.
“The interesting thing we found in our study is that with divorce in postmenopausal women, it’s not all negative, at least not in the short term,” she said.
Since many studies on marriage focus on younger women, the investigators were interested in the effects of marital transitions on older women, who are more susceptible to chronic diseases such as cardiovascular disease and diabetes.
Using data from the national WHI, researchers looked at postmenopausal women ages 50 to 79 over a three-year period. The women fell into one of four groups: those who went from single to married or in a self-defined marriage-like relationship over the course of three years; those who started out married but went through a separation or divorce; and those whose marital status did not change over the three-year period (they either started out and remained married or started out and remained unmarried).
Researchers looked at a number of health measures, including weight, waist circumference and blood pressure, as well as health indicators such as diet, exercise, smoking and alcohol consumption.
All of the women who started the study unmarried (either they had never been married, were divorced or were widowed) saw some weight gain over the three-year period, which is not uncommon for women as they age.
However, those who went from unmarried to married gained slightly more weight than those who remained single — on the order of two or more additional pounds than their unmarried counterparts.
While the reason for the extra weight gain is not entirely clear, one theory on marriage-related weight gain at any age is that it may come from couples sitting down more often together for regular, sometimes larger, meals.
Women who stayed married gained about two pounds and saw a slight increase in their waistline over the three-year study period, while women who divorced lost a modest amount of weight and went down some in inches. The married women also saw a decline in physical activity, while divorced women’s physical activity increased. Alcohol consumption remained about the same between the two groups.
The researchers controlled for women’s self-reported emotional well-being and found that the divorced women’s weight loss did not appear to be related to depression. That is, women weren’t simply eating less and losing weight as an emotional response.
With regard to dietary quality, all women in the study showed improvements in the ratio of healthy to unhealthy food consumed. However, women who went from married to divorced had the most improved diets.
The one area in which divorced women lagged was smoking. Women who went from married to divorced were the most likely group to start smoking. However, it’s important to note that those who picked up the habit were typically former smokers, not first-time tobacco users, Dr. Kutob said.
While the study’s results don’t challenge existing research on the long-term health benefits of marriage, they offer new insight into some of the more immediate health effects of late-life marital transitions, and this could have important implications for postmenopausal women and their health-care providers, Dr. Kutob said.
Other UA co-authors on the marital transitions study are Dr. Nicole P. Yuan, associate professor of public health and assistant professor of psychology; Dr. Betsy C. Wertheim, assistant scientific investigator at the UA Cancer Center; and Dr. David Sbarra, UA professor of psychology. Additional collaborators were from the Brown University School of Public Health; University of California, Davis; University of Texas Health Science Center; University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill; and University of Iowa.
Relationship Between Marital Transitions, Health Behaviors, and Health Indicators of Postmenopausal Women: Results from the Women’s Health Initiative
Journal of Women’s Health. 2017