Connect

Member Research and Reports

Member Research and Reports

Rutgers Study Examines Negative Media Portrayals and Police Treatment of African American Men

A recent study co-authored by Rutgers School of Public Health assistant professor, Dr. Pamela Valera, found that negative portrayals in the news media affect how police treat African American men in the United States.

The study was based on the premise that public perceptions of male dangerousness are a factor in influencing police action and the public’s willingness to accept an officer’s deadly actions as legitimate. It also noted that black masculinity is often equated with hypermasculinity, criminality, and hypersexuality.

“Unarmed black Americans are five times more likely to be shot and killed by police than unarmed white Americans. We believe that media may play a significant role in these disproportionate deaths,” said lead author, Dr. Valera, an assistant professor. “The stereotypes held, consciously or unconsciously, about the criminality and ‘dangerousness’ of black men influence the rates at which they are stopped and engaged by the police.”

To illustrate their premise, researchers reviewed coverage in three newspapers — The New York TimesLos Angeles Times and The Washington Post — of Michael Brown, an unarmed teenager in Ferguson, Missouri, who was shot to death in 2014 by Darren Wilson, a white police officer. The newspapers were selected due to their high potential to impact public opinion.

The researchers examined how the media framed the perceived masculinity of Mr. Brown and Mr. Wilson in covering the case. In particular, they examined how the three newspapers used Mr. Wilson’s account of the event in their descriptions of Mr. Brown. The newspapers depicted Mr. Brown through Mr. Wilson’s testimony as a man of large physical size with uncontrollable aggression, but neglected the fact that the two men were of comparable size. For example, one account describes how Mr. Wilson compares himself holding on to Mr. Brown’s arm to “a 5-year-old trying to hold on to Hulk Hogan.”

“Newspapers use sensational words to get hits. However, the words they used depicted Brown as a monster,” Dr. Valera said. “Language is critical to public perception. The media should tone down emotion in its reporting.”

The researchers also analyzed the words used to describe Brown and Wilson’s socioeconomic class and neighborhoods. Brown’s status was framed by descriptions of his neighborhood: “trappings of a working-class haven” with an “edge of frustration and anger.” Conversely, Wilson was portrayed as having overcome a troubled childhood to make a life in a suburban neighborhood with “brick ranch-style homes” and “manicured lawns.”

“This is just one snapshot of a larger, ongoing problem of aggression toward black men based on racial bias perpetuated by negative stereotypes in the media,” said Dr. Valera. “Since the perceptions that Wilson held of Brown are indicative of more general attitudes of black men, it is vital that police be engaged in more intensive training to become aware of the stereotypes and implicit biases they hold, especially regarding the communities with which they have constant contact.”

“Framing Physicality and Public Safety: A study of Michael Brown and Darren Wilson,” was recently published in Research in Race and Ethnic Relations.